The Elmo sticker and Play-Doh reward system worked for a while, but that had run its course by early February. I could no longer read a few books and leave Sarah in bed to fall asleep on her own because she wouldn't -- she'd get out of bed and into mischief. I started sitting in the rocking chair in her room so she'd lie quietly and fall asleep. I'd give her 30 minutes, and most of the time, she'd nap.
That lost its charm a week or so ago, and she began taunting me -- rolling around, sitting up, dangling her legs off the bed, whatever she could do to get a rise out of me. I finally decided it was time to give up, and yesterday we "officially" switched to quiet time. She has to stay in her room quietly reading books or playing with her stuffed animals (or anything, really, since I can't control what she does) for half an hour. She did pretty well, calling me only a couple of times. I hope we can work our way up to an hour so that I have a bit of a break to get things (like blogging) done.
Meanwhile, our nights have been challenging once again. As a result of my sitting in her room at naptime (I believe), Sarah started wanting me there at bedtime, too. I agreed to sit in the hall while she fell asleep, which often took 45 minutes or more. Soon, she was waking and crying during the night and insisting I sleep with her. Before I knew it, I was back in her bed most nights and feeling resentful. [Probably some of you are thinking that we're letting Sarah manipulate us and we should put our foot down, close the door, and let her cry herself to sleep. I won't say you're wrong; I'll only say that's not right for us (and you might agree if you could hear Sarah in hysterics behind the closed door).]
Through all of our sleep struggles, I've often heard from other adoptive families who co-slept with their children and believed it was the answer for them -- their kids felt secure, and everyone got a good night's sleep. We had planned to do this with Sarah from the start, but she was such an active sleeper that Don and I would have gotten no rest with the three of us in our queen-sized bed. Since a king-sized bed would barely fit in our room (and be a big expense), we've tried to comfort Sarah by my sleeping in her room whenever she needs me.
When we moved Sarah to a full-sized bed in October, I devised a "nuclear option" for our sleep struggles. I resolved to sleep with her when she needed until I started feeling resentful, then we would put her crib mattress on the floor of our room, and she could sleep there. Having reached the resentment threshold, I hauled the mattress back upstairs and made a cozy nest between my side of the bed and the wall. I showed it to Sarah and told her that, if she woke in the middle of the night, she could come in and sleep there. You should have seen her eyes light up.
The first evening, she wanted to go to bed in the "little bed," but I held firm and told her she always has to go to sleep in her big bed first. (I draw the line at putting her to bed in our room -- that's too disruptive for Don and me, and it seems as though it would only compound the difficulty of eventually getting her to spend the night in her own room.) That night, she awoke crying at 4:15. When I went in, she asked me to sit in the hall. I asked if she wanted to sleep in the little bed, to which she responded, "YES!" She settled into the nest and slept until 7:20.
Soon she was waking and crying between 11:00 and 12:00 each night. I'd go in; she'd say, "Little bed;" and I'd escort her into our room. After a while, I convinced her that she didn't need to cry (she was obviously faking it by then), so she now just calls for me. I hope eventually she'll just quietly come in and go to sleep, but that might take a while.
Since the little bed appeared, Sarah is noticeably happier and more affectionate. She is also less controlling and defiant. I think she feels more secure. She still has meltdowns and struggles to control her emotions, but she is improving there, too. An unexpected perk of the little bed has been progress with potty training. She's been good during the day for a couple of months but was still wet at night. Now, she goes potty before coming to the little bed and is often dry all night.
With waking in the night handled, that just left sitting in the hall at bedtime to deal with. While my iPad was a lifesaver for that situation, Sarah had become a wiseguy then as well and started challenging me by playing with her animals and getting out of bed. She obviously was not ready for sleep at 7:30 if she'd had a nap. The End of Napping has taken care of that. I now turn out her light (after books, prayer, and massage) and go across the hall to our room, where I get ready for bed. She's happy as long as our light is on, and she's usually asleep in about five minutes. I can't tell you how refreshing that is.
I had really hoped that Sarah would nap until she was four. I know naps are important for young brains and bodies, but I've tried everything I can think of, and I'm out of ideas. With letting go comes relief. I no longer have to structure my day so she doesn't nap too late, then spend 20 minutes on a pre-nap routine that was often followed by 30 more minutes of struggle, ending all-too-often in anger. While Sarah can be a little whiny and testy by dinner time, she does surprisingly well without a nap, and bedtime is a breeze, which saves me another 45 minutes or more of sitting and waiting for her to fall asleep. She sleeps 11-12 hours at night now, compared to about 10 when she was napping, which isn't bad, either.
And, finally, I can stop feeling like a hypocrite. It was tough insisting that Sarah nap when I'm basically incapable of it. I don't know how old I was when I stopped napping, but, as an adult, I've done it only a handful of times (when I was literally on a deserted island or remote peninsula). Try as I might, I can't wind down during the day, no matter how tired I am. I'm usually out like a light at bedtime, however, and, left to my own devices, good for 10 hours or more. Sarah seems to be wired the same way. Like mother, like daughter. :)






